I've got a WiP on Tom Riddle's school days, that's been going for some time, so I've done a lot of research on him.
Since what Tom was doing was so secret, and I doubt he counted Min as a great friend as she was a Gryffindor and two years older than him, the memories she would have of him would be of the 'false' him and of little use to Harry and Dumbledore.
Minerva is a Gryffindor, she's such a brave and magnificent woman - she survived 4 stunning spells to the chest - I think if she knew anything about Riddle, she would have told Dumbledore immediately.
Hey, everyone's theories are valid until disproven though, I'm not knocking anything. I just think, personally, that Minerva would do anything to help Dumbledore destroy Voldemort, especially if all she was asked to do is provide a memory.
no subject
Date: 2006-01-11 12:32 am (UTC)Since what Tom was doing was so secret, and I doubt he counted Min as a great friend as she was a Gryffindor and two years older than him, the memories she would have of him would be of the 'false' him and of little use to Harry and Dumbledore.
Minerva is a Gryffindor, she's such a brave and magnificent woman - she survived 4 stunning spells to the chest - I think if she knew anything about Riddle, she would have told Dumbledore immediately.
Hey, everyone's theories are valid until disproven though, I'm not knocking anything. I just think, personally, that Minerva would do anything to help Dumbledore destroy Voldemort, especially if all she was asked to do is provide a memory.
I love discussions :D
Nighty night!