(no subject)
Dec. 18th, 2005 01:34 amJust a random thought for the evening, half formed but intriguing.
I'm not sure about this, so feel free to disagree/discuss this with me, but there are a lot of times during penseive memories in HBP that we are given references about how attractive Tom Riddle is.
Now, we assume that the memories that we are seeing came from the person who wasn't Voldemort, in each memory.
But I'm curious. What if they were not.
What if they came from someone else who was present. Someone who found Tom Riddle attractive?
I must admit even when I was reading I found the lack of McGonagall memories conspicuous.
When did she register as an animagus? What if the memories came not from the people in them, but from a silver and black tabby cat that happened to be present?
Just thoughts. Feel free to agree or rebutt.
I'm not sure about this, so feel free to disagree/discuss this with me, but there are a lot of times during penseive memories in HBP that we are given references about how attractive Tom Riddle is.
Now, we assume that the memories that we are seeing came from the person who wasn't Voldemort, in each memory.
But I'm curious. What if they were not.
What if they came from someone else who was present. Someone who found Tom Riddle attractive?
I must admit even when I was reading I found the lack of McGonagall memories conspicuous.
When did she register as an animagus? What if the memories came not from the people in them, but from a silver and black tabby cat that happened to be present?
Just thoughts. Feel free to agree or rebutt.